Heidi Carico

Thank you, Cheryl. If you ever want to see his contradictions, just let me know and I’ll email them to you. 🙂

And Jn 3:16 refutes limited atonement completely, as does 1 Jn 2:2, 1 Tim. 4:9-10, 2 Co. 5:14-15, 1 Jn 4:14, Jn 1:29. The premise behind limited atonement is that if Jesus died for everyone then everyone would be saved. Jesus says that’s false in Jn 3:16. He tells us that God’s love for the world does NOT save the whole world. Only those who BELIEVE in Jesus will be saved. VERY simple. But Matt actually contradicted that on his FB page a few months ago when he said that anyone who REJECTS Christ’s love will be condemned.

What love? According to Matt, Jesus didn’t offer any love to the people in hell because Matt claims that Jesus didn’t die for them. 😉

There are MANY such contradictions on the Carm website. I’ve listed many of them.

Yes I read Rachel Slick’s article and wasn’t at all surprised. Matt hates me almost as much as he hates you. But Matt has a dilemma; he cannot copy our email exchanges because then everyone will SEE that HE was the one attacking my personality and gave me NO Scripture to refute anything I said. He knew I had exposed his contradictions through Scripture and he couldn’t refute them. That is why I’m not listed on his website under “Responding to Critics.” But he did try to mock my emails on his radio show when I wasn’t there to explain my meaning but he had to take my statements completely out of context to do it. So I called into his radio show to prove why 1 Co. 2:14 is right and he hung up on me. So I do know how deceitful he is.

I actually think that Matt is dangerous…not in the physical sense but in his hatred for those who expose his errors. He borders on paranoia, seeing anyone who doesn’t agree with his teachings as a hater who’s out to get him. But this isn’t about Matt, it’s about what Scripture says which he seems to care very little about when people expose his errors. He’s only interested in justifying himself, not in making sure that he’s honoring God with his teachings and behavior so he sees rebuke as hate rather than love.

Pr. 9:8, “Do not rebuke a mocker or he will hate you. Rebuke a wise man and he will love you.”

I feel the need to share my experience with Matt Slick since I have found him to be one of the biggest hypocrites in the professing church today. My history with Matt has gone on for over 10 years and I have received NOTHING from Matt but personal attacks for the abundance of Scripture I’ve sent him through emails. Yet he has never once even tried to refute me through Scripture, since he’s never even QUOTED a Scripture verse to me much less discussed Scripture with me. He’s only called me names and I even believe in election, predestination, total depravity! But I don’t believe in Limited atonement. So out of all the emails he’s received in opposition to his teachings, I probably agree with his beliefs more than most of his opponents yet’s he’s been NOTHING but hostile and verbally abusive to me. There are many contradictions on the Carm website that I have diligently and specifically exposed and the following responses are all I ever get from him;

“You’re ignorant, you’re foolish, you’re arrogant, you’re a hater, you’re not very nice, you’re insulting, you’re condescending, you’re horrible at theology, you don’t know what you’re talking about, you have personality flaws, you can’t write well, you’re whacked, and on and on and on. NO Scripture, NO dialogue about Scripture and no Scriptural proof that I’m wrong.

Not one Scripture verse or explanation through Scripture proving anything I said to be false, just verbal abuse. Now this is a man who said this on his website: “Also, we are to refute false doctrines, false religions, and whatever else might contradict the word of God, but we are to do this WITHOUT INSULT (1 Pet. 3:15), if per chance God would grant them repentance (2 Tim. 2:25).”

Yet ALL he has done is insult me. When his insults got particularly nasty, my husband was appalled so he sent an email to Matt. Matt’s response was to send my husband the emails I sent to Carm WITHOUT sending Matt’s responses to my emails. So my husband saw my emails which contained MUCH Scripture proving limited atonement to be false and NO responses from Matt calling me names. But thankfully, I had Matt’s responses on MY computer so my husband saw all the nasty names that Matt called me and knew from that point on, that Matt is dishonest, manipulative and an impostor.

So I followed Mt. 18:15-17 and confronted Matt on his sins against me but he just ignored that passage, showing more contempt for Scripture. So verse 17 tells me to treat him like an unbeliever.

I also have a list of MANY of Matt’s false teachings which I have sent to him but he either ignores them or calls me names. So NOW I am going public with Matt’s hypocrisy, inability to handle correction, unbiblical teachings, hatred, and unbiblical behavior since I’ve found that there’s no point in trying to contact him personally because expecting an adult response much from him (much less a Scriptural response) is an exercise in futility.