Sye's ultimate evidential claim: everything proves God's existence because you cannot make sense of evidence itself without God — he is 'the ultimate evidentialist'

Sye says: not just some evidences prove God — all evidences prove God, because the very concept of evidence requires God as its ground. Without God, there is no reliable way to evaluate evidence. He is willing to call himself the ultimate evidentialist on those terms. Winger asks about the gospel being preached to Abraham — Galatians 3:8 says 'the Scripture... preached the gospel to Abraham beforehand.' Sye acknowledges this is a mystery — John the Baptist was filled with the Spirit in the womb — but it is consistent with saving faith always being in Christ.