Q&A: False conversion followed by genuine salvation — should the person be re-baptized?

Winger recommends handling this individually with a godly spiritual leader. If the person is unsettled and would find peace in being baptized as a genuine expression of real faith, he would counsel them to do it. However, he warns against using repeated baptism as a band-aid for conscience rather than resting in Christ's finished work. The deeper issue is trusting that Jesus is enough, not hanging assurance on an outward sign.