Universal atonement does not guarantee universal salvation; receiving Christ requires a personal decision.

Winger uses John 1 to show that Jesus came to testify to the light for all, yet many did not receive him. The key distinction is that Jesus acts for all but individuals must receive him. John 1:12 states that only those who receive him and believe in his name are given the right to become children of God. Salvation is likened to a marriage proposal — the offer is made but a personal yes is required. The meal analogy: making a meal for all neighbors does not feed those who do not show up.