Browse / Mike Winger / Idea

Some atheists are driven to deny their own existence to maintain naturalism — Rosenberg (The Atheist's Guide to Reality), Harris, Dennett all deny the reality of the self/consciousness. This is self-refuting: someone must be having the illusion.

How Free Will Conflicts with Atheism (Dr. Tim Stratton) 01:03:59 – 01:05:01

Consequence of determinism: denial of self-existence

Alex Rosenberg in The Atheist's Guide to Reality denies his own existence to preserve atheism. Sam Harris and Daniel Dennett say the self/consciousness is an illusion. But as Descartes noted ("I think therefore I am"), someone must be having the illusion — the very fact of having an experience proves a subject exists. Stratton and Winger see this as a reductio ad absurdum of naturalism: "In order to deny the existence of God, they have to deny their own existence." This is where consistent atheistic naturalism leads when followed to its logical conclusions.

Your Tags

Personal labels you apply to any item — separate from system topics. Tags are shared across all databases. Visit /tags to browse all your tags.

...more

Ask Claude about this