Browse / Mike Winger / Idea

Key examples of alleged literary devices: (1) John moved the temple cleansing from Passion Week to early ministry; (2) John invented "I thirst" on the cross as a theological symbol; (3) Matthew's raised saints as "special effects." McGrew argues all are unnecessary — simpler historical explanations exist.

The Controversy Over "Literary Devices" in The Gospels with Dr. Lydia McGrew 00:03:39 – 00:20:04

Examples of literary devices McGrew disputes

Temple cleansing: the theory says John moved it from late to early ministry. McGrew believes there were simply two cleansings. "I thirst": theory says John invented it as private symbolism for feeling forsaken; McGrew notes Jesus was on the cross for 3 hours — he could have said both things. Raised saints (Matthew 27): Licona called this "special effects" — apocalyptic symbolism emphasizing the event's magnitude. McGrew notes this is rolled in with the earthquake, which Matthew says the centurion SAW, making it look very realistic. Licona's 2017 book went further with invisible devices — e.g., claiming "John appears deliberate in his attempt to lead readers to think the Last Supper was not a Passover meal" when it was. These are invisible within the text, unlike recognizable figures of speech.

Your Tags

Personal labels you apply to any item — separate from system topics. Tags are shared across all databases. Visit /tags to browse all your tags.

...more

Ask Claude about this