Lin

“When you put it this way, Lin it sounds like “This makes no sense in the context of when both sinned out of rebellion”. So I’d word it rather as “this makes no sense in the context after Adam rebels against God and Eve was deceived but came out of her deception. And then it can make sense, no?”

I am not sure how I can help what it sounds like. I never once said Eve sinned out of rebellion. She was deceived. We are talking about her actions after the warning from God when she followed Adam out of the Garden.

My point was why did God have to warn her about something she was supposedly already doing that was good?