Don

I know not to trust satan and my non-trust extends to not thinking he needs to be consistent with my understanding of logic.

There are logic puzzles where an island is inhabited by 2 types of people, those that always tell the truth and those that always lie, one can ask a tricky question such as “If I were to ask you about this, what would you say?”  The truth teller tells the truth and the liar lies about the lie he would say and so tells the truth in the puzzle.  But I do not think satan is limited in this way.

Another way to think of it is the evidence of satan is to be ignored, one cannot rely on it one way or the other.