Browse / Theology / Argument Library
Other John 20:15-17 ●●○○○

Mary Magdalene Commissioned to Announce the Resurrection (John 20:15-17)

Mary Magdalene resurrection commission apostola apostolorum witness egalitarian

Summary

Jesus deliberately chose Mary Magdalene as the first resurrection witness and commissioned her to announce the gospel to the apostles. She is the apostle to the apostles — sent with a theological message that forms the basis of Christian faith. This is not incidental but paradigmatic: God uses women as proclaimers of His most important truths.

The Opposing Argument

Complementarians acknowledge that Mary Magdalene encountered the risen Jesus first but argue this does not establish a precedent for women in teaching or leadership roles. They note that Jesus sent her to the disciples (men) who then became the authoritative witnesses, and that Mary herself was not included among the Twelve or given an ongoing teaching office.

Egalitarian Response

1. Jesus chose Mary as the first witness of the resurrection — this was deliberate, not accidental. In a culture where women's testimony was legally inadmissible (Josephus, Antiquities 4.8.15; m. Shevu. 4:1), Jesus appeared first to a woman and commissioned her to announce the resurrection. If the Gospel writers were fabricating a story, they would never have chosen a female witness — her testimony would have undermined credibility. The fact that all four Gospels record women as the first witnesses is a mark of historical authenticity and a deliberate divine choice. God chose the least credible witness by cultural standards, overturning human hierarchies.

2. Jesus commissions Mary with an apostolic message: "Go and tell my brothers." The command ὕπαγε πρὸς τοὺς ἀδελφούς μου ("go to my brothers") + εἰπὲ αὐτοῖς ("tell them") is a commissioning formula. Jesus sends Mary with a message about His resurrection and ascension — the core of the gospel. The church fathers recognized this: Hippolytus of Rome (3rd century) and later Bernard of Clairvaux called Mary the apostola apostolorum — "the apostle to the apostles." She was sent (ἀποστέλλω — the root of "apostle") to proclaim the resurrection to the very men who would become the church's foundational leaders.

3. The content of Mary's message is theological proclamation, not mere personal testimony. Jesus does not say "tell them you saw me." He gives her a specific theological message: "I am ascending to my Father and your Father, and my God and your God." This is a declaration of Christ's unique relationship with the Father and the believers' adoption into that family. Mary is entrusted with teaching content — Christological and soteriological truth — and commissioned to deliver it to the male disciples.

4. The disciples believed on the basis of a woman's proclamation. John 20:18 — "Mary Magdalene went and announced to the disciples, 'I have seen the Lord.'" The foundation of the disciples' resurrection faith began with a woman's testimony and proclamation. If women are inherently unsuited to proclaim theological truth to men, the entire foundation of Christianity rests on an illegitimate act.

Summary

Jesus deliberately chose Mary Magdalene as the first resurrection witness and commissioned her to announce the gospel to the apostles. She is the apostle to the apostles — sent with a theological message that forms the basis of Christian faith. This is not incidental but paradigmatic: God uses women as proclaimers of His most important truths.

Linked Passages (1)

John 20:15-17 📖 (Explore →)

Primary verse for this claim (John 20:15-17)

Your Tags

Personal labels you apply to any item — separate from system topics. Tags are shared across all databases. Visit /tags to browse all your tags.

...more

Ask Claude about this