Does "Each One" Include Women?
Summary
Some complementarians concede that women may participate in informal contributions (psalms, tongues) but argue that "teaching" and "revelation" are restricted to men when exercised authoritatively. Others argue that 14:26 describes an ideal that is then qualified by 14:34-35, which restricts women. On this reading, "each one" is a general principle that the silence command narrows.
The Opposing Argument
Some complementarians concede that women may participate in informal contributions (psalms, tongues) but argue that "teaching" and "revelation" are restricted to men when exercised authoritatively. Others argue that 14:26 describes an ideal that is then qualified by 14:34-35, which restricts women. On this reading, "each one" is a general principle that the silence command narrows.
Egalitarian Response
1. "Each one" is unqualified and Paul does not narrow it. If Paul intended to restrict "each one has a teaching" to males, he had the vocabulary to do so — he could have written "each man" (hekastos aner). He did not. The universal language stands, and interpreting a later restriction (vv.34-35) as narrowing it requires reading vv.34-35 as Paul's own command — which the quotation interpretation contests (see 14:34-37 and 14:33b-35 entries).
2. The list includes high-authority speech acts. Revelation (apokalypsis) is not a minor contribution — it is the direct disclosure of divine truth. If "each one" may bring a revelation, then each one may perform the most authoritative speech act available in Pauline worship. Gender-restricting "teaching" while allowing "revelation" is incoherent, since revelation carries at least as much authority as instruction.
3. The edification standard is gender-blind. Paul's sole criterion is edification (oikodome). He does not add "and the speaker must be male." If a woman's teaching edifies, it passes the only test Paul establishes. Adding a gender requirement imports a criterion Paul does not state.
4. This verse describes the same assembly where 11:5 presupposes women speaking. The "when you assemble" (synerchesthe) of 14:26 is the same gathering Paul discusses in 11:2-16, where women pray and prophesy publicly. The assembled church that Paul envisions is participatory for all — men and women alike.
5. Paul's conclusion confirms universal participation. Verse 31: "For you can all (pantes) prophesy one by one." Verse 39: "Therefore, my brethren, desire earnestly to prophesy, and do not forbid to speak in tongues." Paul's own summary of ch. 14's argument is "all may prophesy" and "do not forbid." These conclusions are consistent with the universal participation of v.26 and inconsistent with a gender-based silence rule.
The "Orderly Participation" Objection
Some argue that 14:26 describes a disorderly situation Paul is correcting — "when you assemble, each one [tries to contribute at once]" — and that Paul's solution includes silencing women. Response: Paul's correction in vv.27-33 is about orderly turn-taking (one at a time, with interpretation), not about restricting who may speak. The solution to disorder is order, not exclusion. Paul never restricts participation based on identity — only based on edification and orderliness.
Linked Passages (1)
Primary verse for this claim (1 Corinthians 14:26)
Your Tags
Personal labels you apply to any item — separate from system topics. Tags are shared across all databases. Visit /tags to browse all your tags.
...more
Personal labels you apply to any item — separate from system topics. Tags are shared across all databases. Visit /tags to browse all your tags.
...more