Mark

Lydia,

I find it fascinating that you say Christians talk about ‘gifts’ not roles. I think there is an element of truth to your claim, but i also think ‘gift’ based theologies and practices are increasingly becoming unbiblical. Any ‘gift’ that is bestowed will always be in accord with Biblical revelation. Not only that who decides that one is ‘gifted’.

I recommend you read ‘Stirrings of the Soul’ by Mike Raiter. He surveys the rise of ‘pentacostalism’ which i think is intrinsically linked in with the modern ‘gift’ based theologies. It is fascinating to see the rise of charistmatic theology and practice along with the incorporation of eastern religious practices due to modern travel etc. Within our western culture, ‘spirituality’ is big business…just ask any new age movement or health, wealth and prosperity teachers. Australia’s own ‘Hillsong’ church is living testimony to this- it’s a multi million dollar corporation.

As in relation to culture wars, the egalitarian ‘gift’ based interpretations of scripture and practice may not be so innocent as you seemingly hint at. We are all products of our culture, egalitarianism included and probably more so than any other.