Filter results by source database — Scripture Commentary, Theology, Mike Winger, or Pulpit. Click a tab to narrow to one database.

...more
All (5) Mike Winger (5)
Mike Winger idea 2018-11-28

The only detailed source for Apollonius is Philostratus, writing around 215–225 AD — approximately 125 years after Apollonius's death. Philostratus himself expresses uncertainty about details, contradicts himself (e.g., says Apollonius had incredible memory at 100, then says he doesn't know how old he was when he died), and was commissioned by Empress Julia Domna to promote Apollonius worship in Rome.

historical reliability apologetics Apollonius of Tyana
Mike Winger idea 2018-11-28

The single raising-the-dead story in the Life of Apollonius (book 4, ch. 45) is immediately qualified — Philostratus himself says he doesn't know if the woman was really dead (steam rising from her face in the rain suggests she may have been breathing) or if Apollonius actually raised her. This is not comparable to the bodily resurrection of Christ.

resurrection apologetics Apollonius of Tyana
Mike Winger idea 2018-11-28

Philostratus records four possible accounts of what happened to Apollonius at the end of his life: (1) no one saw him die because he deliberately sent Damus away, (2) he died in Ephesus tended by two maidservants, (3) he walked into the temple of Athena at Lindus and disappeared, (4) he walked into a Cretan temple at night, the dogs fawned on him, he loosened his bonds, and a chorus of maidens sang 'hasten to heaven.' None of these accounts is a death and resurrection.

resurrection ascension apologetics
Mike Winger idea 2018-11-28

Apollonius was born around 15 AD — meaning when Jesus was crucified, Apollonius was still a young man. His public career began after Jesus's ministry and death. More critically, all New Testament documents were written within the first century AD, within the lifetimes of eyewitnesses, while Philostratus wrote 125+ years after Apollonius died. If any borrowing occurred, Philostratus likely borrowed from Christian categories.

apologetics Apollonius of Tyana chronology
Mike Winger idea 2018-11-28

The primary literary parallel Philostratus is drawing is between Apollonius and Pythagoras, not Jesus. He explicitly says Apollonius 'performed the same feat as Pythagoras' at Ephesus. Apollonius even claims to be a reincarnation of Euphorbus, a fighter at the Battle of Troy. Any apparent parallels to Jesus are incidental or deliberate anti-Christian swipes by Philostratus.

apologetics Apollonius of Tyana Pythagoras