Can Christians use both evidential and presuppositional approaches? Winger says yes; Sye says you can use evidence presuppositionally but you cannot combine the two methodologies as co-equal

Sye: using evidences in a presuppositional framework is fine. Paul Taylor of the Creation Museum is cited as a good example of evidence used presuppositionally. But the methodology of evidentialism (evidence to convince) and presuppositionalism (evidence to expose suppressed knowledge) are in conflict. You cannot combine them as methodologies; you can use evidence within the presup framework. He warns against 'giving up presuppositions' when presenting evidence.