Filter results by source database — Scripture Commentary, Theology, Mike Winger, or Pulpit. Click a tab to narrow to one database.

...more
All (28) Mike Winger (28)
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-29

Q&A: Can an atheist legitimately argue about a God they don't believe exists?

Viewer question: isn't it a contradiction for an atheist to argue about God using a Bible they don't believe?

Atheist arguments Moral argument for God Logical consistency
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Introduction: Winger critiques presuppositional apologetics, uses Sye Ten Bruggencate as the model, invites Sye to respond live

Opening of the livestream debate; Winger sets the agenda and rules

Mike Winger presuppositional apologetics debate format
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Sye acknowledges Winger's critique as kind though erroneous; notes soteriology will be a central difference underlying their apologetic disagreement

Sye's opening statement and introduction

Calvinism soteriology presuppositional apologetics
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Winger argues his objections to presuppositionalism are biblical, not soteriological, and would hold even if he were Calvinist

Winger's clarification before asking Sye to explain presuppositionalism

biblical authority soteriology presuppositional apologetics
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Sye explains presuppositionalism: start with the presupposition that God exists and his Word is true; all reasoning depends on God; the 'circle' is virtuous, not vicious

Sye's core explanation of the presup method, tracing it to Van Til and Bahnson

Romans 11:36 epistemology presuppositional apologetics Van Til
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Sye challenges Winger with the concept of epistemic certainty vs. psychological certainty; presses him on whether God's existence can fail to be true

Sye's Socratic method applied to Winger

existence of God presuppositional apologetics epistemic certainty
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Winger openly admits he uses reason to discover truth but not to determine it; Sye argues this distinction shows reason is not autonomous — which is the presup point

Discussion of autonomous reason vs. God-dependent reason

1 Corinthians 15 1 Corinthians 15 presuppositional apologetics autonomous reason
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Sye reframes 1 Kings 18: Elijah was not convincing people of something unknown but displaying God's glory to suppressors of truth; the event was judgment, not persuasion

Sye's counter-reading of 1 Kings 18

1 Kings 18 judgment presuppositional apologetics 1 Kings 18
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Sye argues that every non-presuppositional argument for God is probabilistic, not certain, which is inconsistent with how Scripture speaks about God

Broad methodological critique of evidential and classical apologetics

presuppositional apologetics evidential apologetics probabilistic arguments
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Winger accuses Sye of reading his presup philosophy into the Genesis 3 text rather than reading it exegetically; notes Scripture distinguishes Adam (knowing) from Eve (deceived)

Winger's exegetical pushback on Sye's Genesis 3 reading

Genesis 3 1 Timothy 2:14 Genesis 3 1 Timothy 2:14 hermeneutics
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Sye argues that apologists start with God in church but abandon that starting point when engaging unbelievers — an inconsistency; cites Proverbs 26:4

Sye's broader critique of evidential and classical apologists' inconsistency

Proverbs 26:4-5 presuppositional apologetics Proverbs 26:4-5 consistency in apologetics
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Sye's summary position: biblical apologetics is not about probability; it always starts with God's authority and certainty; all other methods are inconsistent with Scripture

Sye's mid-debate summary

Romans 11:36 biblical authority presuppositional apologetics Romans 11:36
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Question from Ben Thompson: which apologetic method does Jesus use? Sye says most consistent biblical apologetic is answering every objection with Scripture

Audience Q&A on New Testament apologetic methodology

presuppositional apologetics Jesus's apologetic method Scripture as foundation
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Why have fulfilled prophecy in Scripture at all if one should just presuppose the Bible is true? Winger asks Sye to account for the evidential role of prophecy

Winger pressing Sye on the purpose of fulfilled prophecy

fulfilled prophecy presuppositional apologetics Scripture as self-authenticating
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Can Christians use both evidential and presuppositional approaches? Winger says yes; Sye says you can use evidence presuppositionally but you cannot combine the two methodologies as co-equal

Audience question from 'apology of five'; key methodological clarification

presuppositional apologetics evidential apologetics classical apologetics
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Can evidences make someone stop being a Christian? Sye argues if you were converted by evidence, evidence could un-convert you — showing Christ was never Lord of your reasoning

Sye's epistemological test for true faith

resurrection presuppositional apologetics certainty of God
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Colossians 2:2-3 — all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge are hidden in Christ; Sye uses this to ground all epistemology in Christ

Sye's primary Christological epistemology text

Colossians 2:2-3 epistemology presuppositional apologetics Colossians 2:2-3
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Colossians 2:8 and 1 Timothy 6:20 cited by Sye as warnings against 'false knowledge' not founded on Christ — supports the presup epistemological claim

Additional Pauline texts for presup epistemology

Colossians 2:8 1 Timothy 6:20 presuppositional apologetics Colossians 2:8 1 Timothy 6:20
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

1 Peter 3:15 — 'in your hearts honor Christ the Lord as holy, always being prepared to make a defense'; Sye says the verse establishes presuppositional starting point before giving reasons

Key apologetics text interpreted through the presup lens

1 Peter 3:15 presuppositional apologetics 1 Peter 3:15 apologetics method
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

The Great Commission (Matthew 28:18-20): Sye argues it starts with 'all authority has been given to me' — the mandate is to start with Christ's authority, not argue to it

Sye's argument from the Great Commission

Matthew 28:18-20 Great Commission presuppositional apologetics evangelism method
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Q&A — Does presuppositionalism hinge on Romans 1:18-32 being applicable to everyone? Sye: not exclusively, but yes — God is never presented as a probability in Scripture

Audience question from Ben Thompson

Romans 1:18-32 presuppositional apologetics probabilistic arguments certainty of God
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

In a culture of moral relativism, presuppositionalism doesn't prove the Word is true — it shows that you can't make sense of truth without the Word

Audience question about moral relativism; Sye's key presup move

presuppositional apologetics moral relativism truth as borrowed concept
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

The most consistent presuppositional approach is to answer every objection with Scripture; Sye admits he gets too bogged down in philosophy and wants to recover a more Scripture-centered approach

Sye's self-critique and practical apologetics

presuppositional apologetics Scripture as foundation street evangelism
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Book recommendations for comparing apologetic methodologies; Sye recommends Bahnson's 'Always Ready' and 'Presuppositional Apologetics Stated and Defended'; Jason Lisle's 'The Ultimate Proof of Creation'

Audience book recommendation question

John Frame presuppositional apologetics Greg Bahnson Jason Lisle
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Sye's ultimate evidential claim: everything proves God's existence because you cannot make sense of evidence itself without God — he is 'the ultimate evidentialist'

Sye's reframing of himself as a supreme evidentialist

Galatians 3:8 John the Baptist presuppositional apologetics evidence as God-dependent Galatians 3:8
Mike Winger idea 2018-08-16

Practical summary of presuppositionalism: 'Read your Bible, believe what it says, go forth' — start with the authority of God's Word and do not contradict that when talking to unbelievers

Sye's final simplified summary of presuppositionalism

biblical authority presuppositional apologetics Scripture as foundation
Mike Winger idea 2020-09-25

Presuppositional apologetics debate: Mike rejects the claim that evidential apologists need shared worldview common ground

Q&A from Daniel C about whether neutral or common ground exists in apologetics

apologetics presuppositional apologetics evidential apologetics
Mike Winger idea 2020-09-25

Presuppositional apologetics requires assuming Christianity true rather than proving it — Mike disagrees

Specific critique of presuppositionalism

apologetics presuppositional apologetics epistemology