Were Women Apostles in the New Testament? Women in Ministry part 5
Ideas (78)
Series overview: Were women apostles in the New Testament?
Mike introduces part 5 of the Women in Ministry series, focused on the claim that women were apostles.
00:00:05Warning against fence-sitting on divisive issues
Mike urges viewers not to default to neutrality just because the women in ministry debate is heated.
00:00:35Two egalitarian views on women apostles
Mike outlines the two egalitarian arguments that will be addressed in this video.
00:01:07Complementarian views on women apostles
Mike summarizes the complementarian positions on the question.
00:02:08Apostle must mean highest leadership for egalitarian argument to work
Mike emphasizes a key logical requirement of the egalitarian argument.
00:03:08Two egalitarian claims: Mary as apostle to the apostles, and Junia in Romans 16
Mike previews the two main egalitarian arguments he will address.
00:03:40Egalitarian equivocation on the meaning of apostle
Mike flags a recurring problem in egalitarian argumentation.
00:04:10Romans 16:7 text and the translation debate on Junia
Mike reads the ESV translation of Romans 16:7 and introduces the translation controversy.
00:04:40Scholarly consensus favors inclusive reading (Junia as apostle)
Mike acknowledges the current state of scholarly opinion.
00:05:11Translation survey: inclusive vs. exclusive renderings of Romans 16:7
Mike surveys how various English translations handle the phrase.
00:05:41When translations disagree, it signals genuine difficulty
Mike offers a hermeneutical principle for Bible readers.
00:06:11Craig Keener's three arguments for Junia as apostle
Mike introduces egalitarian scholar Craig Keener's case.
00:06:42Keener's first argument: Paul never elsewhere appeals to 'the apostles' as a group
Mike evaluates and rebuts Keener's first argument.
00:08:46Galatians 2:9 as counterexample to Keener's first argument
Mike argues Paul does appeal to apostles as a group elsewhere.
00:09:46Keener's second argument: most natural reading of 'among' implies group membership
Mike presents Keener's second argument.
00:11:16Keener's third argument: Greek church fathers and modern scholars agree Junia was an apostle
Mike considers this the weightiest of Keener's three arguments.
00:11:46The word apostolos has a range of meanings in Greek
Mike explains the semantic range of 'apostle' as groundwork for the next argument.
00:13:17Majority of scholars who affirm Junia as apostle think she was not highest-rank apostle
Mike makes a crucial distinction within the scholarly consensus.
00:14:18Option 1: Junia as highest-sense apostle (like Peter or Paul)
Mike examines the strongest possible egalitarian reading.
00:14:48Keener's argument: no qualifier on 'the apostles' suggests highest sense
Mike presents Keener's supporting argument from Two Views on Women in Ministry.
00:15:50Counterargument: 'well-known among the apostles' proves too much given their obscurity
Mike offers a significant rebuttal to the highest-sense reading.
00:16:51Option 2: Junia as missionary/church planter (lower sense of apostle)
Mike explores the second option for interpreting Junia's apostleship.
00:18:52Payne's claim that Junia had 'authority as ministers of the gospel' is vague
Mike responds to Payne's claim about authority.
00:20:23Linda Belleville thinks Junia was a missionary saved at Pentecost
Mike cites another egalitarian scholar's view.
00:20:53Craig Blomberg's soft complementarian view: missionaries with temporary authority
Mike presents Blomberg's nuanced position from Two Views on Women in Ministry.
00:21:23Women were missionaries in the early church; 'co-workers' means missionary partners
Mike affirms women's roles in early church missions.
00:23:25Soft complementarianism restricts only the elder role to men
Mike defines the soft complementarian position.
00:23:55Tom Schreiner's view: Junia as missionary focused on women's ministry
Mike introduces Schreiner's nuanced addition to the discussion.
00:24:25Ancient gender-separated society created distinct need for female missionaries
Mike develops the historical-cultural argument for gender-specific ministry.
00:25:27Female deacons in the early church focused on ministry to women
Mike provides historical evidence for gender-specific ministry roles.
00:26:29Mike's conclusion assuming Junia was an apostle: she was a missionary, not highest-rank
Mike summarizes his 'fallback' position if Junia was indeed an apostle.
00:27:30The egalitarian 'trump card' of Junia as apostle does not work
Mike's interim conclusion before moving to the Greek syntactical argument.
00:29:31Burer and Wallace 2001 paper defending exclusive reading of Romans 16:7
Mike introduces a key scholarly paper challenging the consensus.
00:30:01Burer-Wallace thesis: consensus arrived at with thin evidence
Mike presents the paper's opening claim.
00:31:01Analogy: scholarly assumption that Jesus didn't speak Greek
Mike draws a parallel to another uncritically absorbed scholarly assumption.
00:31:31Burer-Wallace: 'snowballing dogma with little substance at its core'
Mike quotes from the paper's critique of the consensus.
00:32:01Lexical evidence: episemos can mean either 'well-known among' or 'well-known to'
Mike explains the lexical analysis from the paper.
00:32:32Key distinction: inclusive vs. exclusive reading of episemoi en tois apostolois
Mike clarifies the two interpretive options.
00:33:33Burer-Wallace syntactical argument: dative = 'well known to,' genitive = 'well known among'
Mike explains the core syntactical argument of the paper.
00:35:07Burer-Wallace conclusion: 'almost certainly' means well known to the apostles
Mike quotes the paper's strong conclusion.
00:37:12Richard Bauckham's rebuttal in Gospel Women
Mike introduces the main scholarly pushback against Burer-Wallace.
00:37:42Bauckham reevaluated examples but brought no new counter-evidence
Mike notes a limitation in Bauckham's rebuttal.
00:40:16Michael Burer's 2015 response paper with new evidence
Mike introduces a third round of scholarly debate that he thinks is underappreciated.
00:41:17Burer's 2015 paper brings 71 new supporting texts
Mike details the new evidence Burer marshals.
00:42:18Burer responds to Bauckham's specific example critiques and addresses Chrysostom
Mike evaluates Burer's defense against Bauckham's objections.
00:43:21Mike's conclusion: Junia was probably not an apostle; if she was, she was a missionary
Mike states his overall conclusion on the Junia question.
00:44:53N.T. Wright's claim: Mary Magdalene as 'apostle to the apostles'
Mike introduces and plays a clip from N.T. Wright's lecture.
00:45:53Mike identifies equivocation in Wright's argument about apostle
Mike charges Wright with a logical fallacy.
00:47:27The office of apostle involves more than witnessing the resurrection
Mike distinguishes the office of apostle from mere witness.
00:48:29Mary Magdalene is never called an apostle in Scripture
Mike notes a key absence in the biblical text.
00:49:29Mike critiques N.T. Wright's impact: meme-level arguments persuading many
Mike expresses frustration with the quality of Wright's argument on this topic.
00:50:01Craig Keener's argument: Deborah as an Old Testament apostle equivalent
Mike addresses Keener's claim linking Deborah to apostleship.
00:50:31Better equivalence: women prophets in OT lead to women prophets in NT, not women apostles
Mike argues the egalitarian logic fails on its own terms.
00:52:31Mike's conclusion: no female apostles in the official high-leadership sense
Mike summarizes the positive data section.
00:54:04Negative data: all twelve apostles were men
Mike presents the complementarian argument from the composition of the Twelve.
00:54:35Egalitarian response: cultural reasons prevented women apostles
Mike presents and critiques the standard egalitarian counter-argument.
00:56:07Mike's experience researching egalitarian scholarship: layers of confusion
Mike shares his personal intellectual journey through the literature.
00:57:43Unfalsifiability problem: can we distinguish God's design from cultural accommodation?
Mike challenges the egalitarian method at its core.
00:58:45Jesus chose apostles unlikely to be culturally accepted
Mike argues Jesus did not choose apostles based on cultural acceptability.
00:59:45Philip Payne's argument: traveling with Jesus full-time raised moral suspicions
Mike presents Payne's specific cultural argument.
01:00:45Mike's rebuttals to Payne: practical solutions and Jesus' counter-cultural behavior
Mike offers multiple objections to Payne's cultural argument.
01:01:47Jesus regularly broke cultural conventions and didn't avoid suspicion
Mike builds his case that Jesus was not concerned with cultural optics.
01:02:48Payne's argument about married women's family obligations
Mike addresses Payne's second cultural objection.
01:03:48Five objections to Payne's cultural argument summarized
Mike itemizes his objections to the cultural-restriction thesis.
01:04:49Women traveled with Jesus and supported him financially
Mike cites biblical evidence that women were already traveling with Jesus.
01:05:51Luke 8:1-3: Women traveled with Jesus like the apostles but were not apostles
Mike cites a key passage showing women's proximity to Jesus.
01:07:21All clear references to apostles indicate male gender
Mike addresses the argument that unnamed apostles might have been women.
01:07:511 Corinthians 9:5 implies all apostles were male with wives who were not apostles
Mike cites a passage he thinks is overlooked in this debate.
01:08:23Egalitarian contradiction: cultural restriction vs. Junia's early prominence
Mike identifies an internal contradiction in egalitarian reasoning.
01:09:26Mike's conclusions on women's roles: high view of women but not apostles
Mike begins his summary conclusions for the video.
01:10:28Soft complementarianism is Mike's conclusion from the evidence
Mike names his overall position.
01:10:58Pushback from previous video on female deacons and 1 Timothy 3:8-13
Mike responds to viewer objections about women as deacons.
01:11:28Verses 12-13 are about men, verse 11 is about women — not gender neutral
Mike clarifies the structure of the 1 Timothy 3 passage on deacons.
01:12:30Your Tags
Personal labels you apply to any item — separate from system topics. Tags are shared across all databases. Visit /tags to browse all your tags.
...more
Personal labels you apply to any item — separate from system topics. Tags are shared across all databases. Visit /tags to browse all your tags.
...more